Melina Palmer Png

Counterfactual Thinking: Why We ‘What If’ And ‘If Only’

Melina Palmer

I love the concept of counterfactual thinking. In fact, it was one of my favorite things to read about in school – I find it to be fascinating in many ways, but perhaps it’s because it relates to something we all do, all the time, and don’t really stop to think about why. And more importantly – we don’t stop to think about if it is doing us harm or good, and how we might control this natural state of the brain.

Counterfactual thinking is a fancy way to say “what if..” or “if only…” Maybe you have memories of your childhood or choices you made, and then think that with a little more discipline (or focus or effort or training) you could have been an actor or doctor or run that marathon. 

We all have regrets on actions taken or not taken, and these are represented in our brains via counterfactual thinking. This may seem like a hurdle to overcome, but it is actually central to being a human being – our emotions and the way we think – and can be a VERY good thing (listen to learn the 1 important step to shift from vicious cycle to goal-achieving awesomeness). Studies have found counterfactual thinking happens across all cultures and as early as 2 years old.

Recommended Reading

Recommended Listening

Marco Palma

Inside the Texas A&M Human Behavior Lab

Marco Palma

Go to Ep. 33
Vanessa Bohns

Unlocking Your Hidden Influence: Revealing the Secrets to Making a Difference

Vanessa Bohns

Go to Ep. 318
Steve Martin

The Influence Equation

Steve Martin

Go to Ep. 455
Amy Bucher

Designing for Behavior Change

Amy Bucher

Go to Ep. 520